Can You Use “I” In A Short Story? Tips For Crafting First-Person Narratives

Published on:
Whenyouwrite is reader supported. When you purchase through referral links on our site, we may earn a commission... Learn more
An image of a person sitting at a desk, surrounded by crumpled pieces of paper and a pen

Have you ever wondered if it’s acceptable to use ‘I’ in a short story? Are you struggling to craft a compelling first-person narrative? Look no further, because this article will provide you with tips and tricks for mastering the art of writing in first person.

When it comes to writing a short story, using first-person narration can be a powerful tool in creating a personal and intimate connection between the reader and the protagonist. However, it’s important to understand the advantages and limitations of this point of view, as well as how to avoid common pitfalls.

With the right techniques, you can create a strong protagonist voice, use sensory details to bring your story to life, and ultimately, captivate your reader’s attention from start to finish.

So, let’s dive in and discover how you can use ‘I’ to craft a compelling and innovative short story.

Key Takeaways

  • First-person narration has advantages such as creating a personal connection and deeper understanding of the character, but also limitations like a limited and biased perspective.
  • Crafting a strong protagonist’s voice is crucial for creating a memorable character, which can be achieved through show vs. tell and balancing emotions and thoughts.
  • Sensory details can bring the story to life and help establish a unique voice.
  • To create effective first-person narratives, writers should focus on relatable characters, balance introspection and action, use descriptive language and dialogue to show emotions and revise for clarity and consistency while avoiding common pitfalls such as over-sharing personal details and self-indulgent writing.

Understand the Advantages and Limitations of First Person Narratives

Let’s dive into the perks and pitfalls of first-person storytelling so you can decide if it’s the right choice for your short story. Writing in first-person allows the reader to experience the story through the protagonist’s perspective, giving them a deeper understanding of the character’s thoughts, feelings, and motivations. It creates a more personal connection between the reader and the protagonist, making the story more engaging and memorable.

However, writing in the first person also has its limitations. The reader’s perspective is limited to the protagonist’s point of view, which can be narrow and biased. It’s important to remember that the protagonist’s perspective may not be entirely accurate or reliable, and the reader may miss out on important information that the protagonist is not aware of.

It’s important to weigh the advantages versus the limitations when deciding whether to use a first-person narrative in your short story.

Create a Strong Protagonist Voice

When you create a strong protagonist voice, you give your readers a reason to care about your character.

Establishing a unique voice for your character is crucial to creating a memorable character. To achieve this, you must balance the character’s emotions and thoughts. Use dialogue and internal monologue effectively.

To really bring your character to life, consider using contractions in their speech. This will make their dialogue sound more natural and believable.

Overall, by structuring your writing in a way that logically groups complete sentences together, you can create a strong and compelling protagonist voice that your readers will love.

creating a memorable character with a unique voice in a short story
Creating a memorable character with a unique voice in a short story

Establishing a Unique Voice for Your Character

As you delve into crafting your first-person narrative, you’ll find that establishing a unique voice for your character is crucial to creating a compelling story. Developing a distinct tone will set your character apart from others and make them more memorable.

But how do you go about creating this unique voice?

One way to establish a unique voice is by showing versus telling effectively. Instead of simply stating your character’s personality traits, show them through their actions and dialogue.

For example, if your character is stubborn, have them refuse to back down in a conflict or argue with others. By doing this, you create a more realistic and relatable character, which will keep your readers engaged throughout the story.

Balancing the Character’s Emotions and Thoughts

To make your readers feel more connected to your character, it’s important to find a balance between their emotions and thoughts. You want your readers to feel like they’re experiencing everything alongside your character, from the highs to the lows.

It’s important to explore vulnerability in your character through their emotions and thoughts, without overwhelming the reader or making them feel disconnected.

One way to balance the emotions and thoughts of your character is by using humor. This can be a great way to lighten the mood of a heavy scene or to show a different side of your character. Humor can also be a way to connect with your readers on a more personal level, as everyone loves a good laugh.

However, it’s important to use humor in a way that fits your character and the overall tone of your story. By balancing your character’s emotions and thoughts, and incorporating humor where appropriate, you can create a unique and engaging first-person narrative that will keep your readers hooked.

Using Dialogue and Internal Monologue Effectively

Using dialogue and internal monologue effectively can breathe life into your character and make them feel more relatable, like a friend you’re having a conversation with. By using dialogue, you can show the reader how the character interacts with others and reveal their personality through their words.

Meanwhile, internal monologue can provide insight into the character’s thoughts and feelings, allowing the reader to understand their motivations and reactions.

To make dialogue more effective, consider using body language to show how the character is feeling. For example, instead of writing “I’m nervous,” you could write “I’m fidgeting with my hands and avoiding eye contact.” This not only shows the character’s nervousness but also adds depth to the scene.

Additionally, incorporating flashbacks through internal monologue can provide context for the character’s actions and add emotional weight to the story. By using these techniques, you can craft a first-person narrative that not only engages the reader but also feels authentic and relatable.

Use Sensory Details to Bring Your Story to Life

You gotta make your readers see, hear, smell, taste, and feel what’s happening so they can experience your story like it’s their own. Using descriptive language and evoking emotions is key to achieving this. Don’t just tell your readers what’s happening, show them. Use sensory details to bring your story to life.

  1. Sight: Describe the colors, shapes, and movements of the objects and people in your story. Use specific details to create a vivid image in your reader’s mind.
  2. Sound: Use onomatopoeia and descriptive language to create sounds that match the actions taking place in your story. For example, instead of saying ‘the car drove away,’ say ‘the engine roared and the tires screeched as the car sped off.’
  3. Smell: Describe the scents in your story, both pleasant and unpleasant. Smells can evoke memories and emotions, so use them to your advantage.
  4. Touch: Describe the textures and sensations of objects and people in your story. Use tactile language to make your readers feel like they are experiencing the story firsthand.

By incorporating sensory details into your story, you can create a fully immersive experience for your readers. They’ll be able to see, hear, smell, taste, and feel what’s happening, which will make your story more memorable and impactful.

making the readers experience the story using descriptive language
Making the readers experience the story using descriptive language

Avoid Common Pitfalls of First-Person Narratives

You’re ready to dive into the world of writing a first-person narrative, but it’s important to avoid common pitfalls that can turn off your readers.

Firstly, it’s important to avoid over-sharing personal details or TMI (too much information).

Secondly, be mindful of not indulging in self-centered or self-indulgent writing that can alienate your audience.

Lastly, find the balance between showing versus telling to keep your readers engaged and invested in the story.

Keep these tips in mind to craft a compelling and relatable first-person narrative.

Avoiding Over-sharing and TMI

Don’t go too far with personal details — it can be tempting to spill everything out onto the page, but it’s important to remember that readers don’t need to know everything about you. Setting boundaries is crucial when crafting a first-person narrative.

Choose relevant details that will help the reader understand your character and their motivations without oversharing. To keep your readers engaged, here are some tips to avoid over-sharing and TMI:

  • Stick to the plot: Anything that doesn’t move the story forward should be left out.
  • Focus on the character: Share details that help the reader understand the character’s personality, background, and motivations.
  • Use sensory details: Instead of describing every thought and feeling, use sensory details to show the character’s state of mind.

By following these tips, you can craft a first-person narrative that is engaging, relevant, and avoids over-sharing. Remember, less is often more when it comes to personal details.

Keep the reader’s imagination engaged, and they’ll be invested in your story till the end.

Avoiding Self-Indulgence

Avoiding self-indulgence is crucial when writing a first-person narrative, as it can distract readers from the story and turn them off.

While it’s important to include some introspection and reflection in your writing, it’s equally important to balance it with action and plot development. Remember that readers are drawn to characters they can relate to, so focus on crafting relatable characters that readers will care about.

One way to avoid self-indulgence is to keep your focus on the main story and avoid going off on tangents or sharing unnecessary details. It’s also helpful to get feedback from beta readers or writing groups to ensure that your writing is not too self-centered.

By maintaining a balance between introspection and action, and creating characters that readers can connect with, you can create a first-person narrative that is engaging and relatable.

Balancing Showing vs. Telling

Now that you’ve learned how to avoid self-indulgence in your first-person narratives, let’s talk about balancing showing versus telling. It’s essential to strike a balance between these two elements to make your story engaging for your readers.

Here are some tips to help you master the art of balancing showing versus telling in your first-person narratives:

  1. Use descriptive language to show your readers what’s happening instead of telling them. For example, instead of saying ‘I was scared,’ describe your character’s physical reactions, such as ‘My heart raced, and my palms became sweaty.’
  2. Use dialogue to show your readers your character’s personality and emotions instead of telling them. For instance, instead of saying ‘I was angry,’ let your character express their emotions through their words and actions.
  3. Avoid cliches and overused phrases that can make your story predictable and unoriginal. Use your unique voice and style to tell your story.
  4. Use sensory details to immerse your readers in your story. Describe the sights, smells, sounds, tastes, and textures your character experiences to make your story come alive.
deciding how to balance showing and telling in a short story
Deciding how to balance showing and telling in a short story

Edit and Revise Your Story for Maximum Impact

As you approach the editing and revision stage of your short story, there are several key points to keep in mind.

First, focus on revising for clarity and consistency throughout your narrative. Secondly, be willing to cut unnecessary details and scenes that don’t contribute to the overall impact of your story.

Finally, seek feedback from beta readers or writing groups to gain valuable insights and perspectives on how to improve your work. By following these steps, you can ensure that your final product is polished, impactful, and ready to be shared with the world.

Revising for Clarity and Consistency

Crafting clear and consistent first-person narratives requires careful revision and consistent choices in language and tone. When revising your story, it’s important to eliminate redundancy and streamline the plot to ensure clarity and consistency.

This means going through each sentence and paragraph with a critical eye, asking yourself if each detail is necessary to move the story forward and if it adds to the overall tone and voice of the narrative.

In addition to eliminating unnecessary details, it’s important to pay attention to the language and tone used in the story. Consistency in language and tone helps to maintain the reader’s engagement and immersion in the story.

Make sure that the language used matches the character’s voice and personality, and that the tone matches the mood and atmosphere of the story. By revising for clarity and consistency, you can ensure that your first-person narrative is a compelling and engaging read for your audience.

Cutting Unnecessary Details and Scenes

Get ready to make your story more engaging by cutting unnecessary details and scenes. One of the biggest mistakes writers make is including too much information that doesn’t move the plot forward. This can bore readers and make them lose interest in your story.

Instead, focus on streamlining the plot progression by eliminating unnecessary details and scenes. To do this, start by identifying the purpose of each scene and detail. If it doesn’t contribute to the overall story, cut it out.

Next, ask yourself if the information can be conveyed in a more concise way. Can you show instead of tell? Can you combine scenes to make them more efficient? Remember, less is often more when it comes to storytelling.

By eliminating unnecessary details and streamlining your plot progression, you can keep your readers engaged and invested in your story.

Seeking Feedback from Beta Readers or Writing Groups

Utilizing beta readers or joining writing groups can enhance the quality of your work and provide valuable feedback to help you improve your writing.

The pros of seeking feedback from beta readers or writing groups are that you get a fresh pair of eyes to evaluate your work, which can help you spot areas that need improvement. You can also get constructive criticism that can help you grow as a writer and improve your craft.

Additionally, feedback from beta readers or writing groups can help you identify areas where your story might be unclear or confusing, allowing you to make necessary revisions.

However, there are also cons to seeking feedback from beta readers or writing groups. Sometimes the feedback can be overwhelming or conflicting, which can make it difficult to know which suggestions to follow. It’s also important to handle criticism in a constructive way and not take it personally.

Remember that feedback is meant to help you improve your writing, not tear you down. Overall, seeking feedback from beta readers or writing groups can be a valuable tool in improving your writing, as long as you approach it with an open mind and a willingness to learn.

Here are some tips on how to properly edit a short story


As you finish crafting your first-person narrative, you may find that using ‘I’ has allowed you to create a strong and relatable protagonist voice. However, it’s important to understand the limitations of this point of view and to use sensory details to bring your story to life.

By immersing your readers in the sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and textures of your story, you can transport them to another world and make them feel as if they’re experiencing the events firsthand. But be wary of common pitfalls such as overusing ‘I’ or failing to fully develop your supporting characters.

With careful editing and revision, you can ensure that your story has maximum impact and leaves a lasting impression on your readers.

So go ahead, dive into your protagonist’s mind, and tell their story with vivid detail and emotional resonance. Your readers will thank you for it.

Photo of author


Jessica started off as an avid book reader. After reading one too many romance novels (really... is it ever really enough?), she decided to jump to the other side and started writing her own stories. She now shares what she has learned (the good and the not so good) here at When You Write, hoping she can inspire more up and coming wordsmiths to take the leap and share their own stories with the world.